Photographers Home Photo Community Critique Requests Along the Sheffield &Tinsley canal again Reply To: Along the Sheffield &Tinsley canal again

IanButty
Admin
Post count: 67

Sorry, it has taken me so long to respond to the images you requested a critique on.

This image doesn’t quite work for me. Sorry. The HDR effect, I think has flattened the contrast/brightness rages a little too much. I am guessing you were trying to bring out the detail in the shadows along the towpath? I think it needs just a fraction more shadow? Also, the white along the edge of the water (bottom centre) is very distracting. I’m not sure if this is a real reflection or an artifact caused by the pseudo-HDR process.

Compositionally the image isn’t bad.